Disclosure: Some links in this article are affiliate links. We may earn a commission on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
The best car wash soap for black cars is a pH-neutral, high-lubricity shampoo with no wax, gloss enhancers or silicone fillers, and CarPro Reset is the pick that covers gloss black and matte black alike. If the additive list is where you get lost, the breakdown of pH-neutral and ceramic-safe car wash soap covers what each ingredient leaves behind on paint.
Black paint is unforgiving in two completely different ways. Gloss black shows swirl marks and drying streaks under any direct light, so lubrication and a residue-free rinse outrank raw cleaning power. Matte black, satin vinyl and factory flat finishes fail the other direction: a soap carrying gloss enhancers, wax or silicone leaves a patchy semi-gloss sheen that cannot be polished out, because matte cannot tolerate abrasion.
Every product below is tagged by lane, because a soap sold specifically for black paint is often the wrong bottle for a matte black car. Dilution ratios come from the manufacturers, and pH is listed as a number only where a manufacturer or an SDS actually publishes one.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Quick Picks
| Pick | Lane | Best for | Matte-safe |
|---|---|---|---|
| CarPro Reset | Both | Overall pick, coated black cars | Yes |
| Chemical Guys Black Light | Gloss | Maximum wet look on black paint | No |
| Adam's Car Wash Shampoo | Both | Best value for a two-car garage | Yes |
| P&S Pearl Auto Shampoo | Both | Slickest feel under the mitt | Yes |
| Gyeon Q²M Bathe | Both | Premium maintenance on coated paint | Yes |
| Griot's Garage Super-Concentrated | Both | Cheapest way into a matte-safe soap | Yes |
| Chemical Guys Meticulous Matte | Matte | Matte and satin specialists | Yes |
| Dr. Beasley's Matte Body Wash | Matte | Purist matte, zero fillers | Yes |
| Meguiar's Gold Class | Gloss | Budget gloss enhancer for waxed paint | No |
| Chemical Guys Mr. Pink | Gloss | Foam volume on a budget | No |
What Makes a Great Car Wash Soap for Black Paint?
Lubricity is the first filter. A shampoo does not lift dirt by itself; its surfactants and polymers encapsulate grit and reduce the friction between that grit, the wash media and the clear coat. Slickness is what buys you margin when a panel is dirtier than you thought, and on black paint that margin is visible within a week.
pH is the second. Most car care sources treat roughly pH 6 to 8 as the neutral band, and anything inside it preserves wax, sealant and ceramic coating across repeated washes. The scale is logarithmic, so a shampoo at pH 6 is ten times more acidic than one at pH 7, which is why a product sitting just outside neutral still behaves very differently over a season. Dish soap sits well above that band and strips protection, which is covered in more detail in why you shouldn't wash a car with Dawn.
Rinsing behaviour is the third and the one black paint punishes hardest. Waxes, gloss polymers, conditioners and silicone fillers all leave a film, and on a dark panel that film shows up as rainbowing and streak lines under sunlight. A pure shampoo rinses to nothing.
Foam volume is not a criterion. Foam's job is to cling to vertical panels and soften the danger layer before your mitt touches anything. Thick suds that carry dirt do more than big bubbles, and a low-foaming concentrate can out-clean a dramatic-looking one.
Gloss, Matte, or Both: Reading a Soap's Label
A soap is gloss-oriented when it contains gloss enhancers, optical brighteners, conditioners or wax. Those ingredients are not defects; they deepen dark paint, mask light swirls and add a little protection. They are also the reason a gloss soap is the wrong bottle for a matte car.
A soap is matte-safe when it carries none of them: no wax, no gloss enhancers, no silicones, no oils, no fillers. Matte finishes get their look from controlled micro-texture, and anything that fills that texture produces a shiny patch. BMW and GM both advise against waxing, polishing or brush-washing factory matte paint for exactly this reason, and once a matte panel has been glossed out there is no polishing it back.
The rule that catches people out: pH-neutral is necessary but not sufficient for matte. A shampoo can sit perfectly at neutral pH and still leave a splotchy sheen because of a gloss polymer in the formula. If the bottle says gloss enhancer, optical brightener or wash and wax, it is a gloss soap regardless of its pH. Ceramic-coating compatibility is a separate question again, and the compatibility guide for coatings on PPF and matte paint goes deeper on what can and cannot sit on a flat finish.
#1 CarPro Reset: Best Overall for Black Cars
Reset is the rare shampoo that is equally correct on a ceramic-coated gloss black daily and on a satin black wrap. It runs at pH 7 using what CarPro calls intelligent pH surfactants, meaning it cleans with the strength of an alkaline wash while staying neutral. The formula carries no gloss enhancers, no polymers and no wax, so it rinses to nothing rather than leaving a film on a dark panel, and it restores water beading on a coating instead of masking it.
Dilution is where it earns its place in a rotation. The label specifies 1:500, or 40 ml in 20 litres, and the manufacturer's bucket range sits at 1:400 to 1:500. In a foam cannon the community runs it around 1:9. It is largely biodegradable and free of harsh SLS.
One caution repeated in high-end shops: Reset is a genuinely strong cleaner. Running it rich over a fresh carnauba wax will cut the wax, so match the dose to what is on the paint rather than pouring heavy out of habit.
Specs:
- pH 7, no gloss enhancers, no polymers, no wax
- Bucket dilution 1:400 to 1:500 (40 ml per 20 L)
- Foam cannon around 1:9
- Safe on gloss, matte, satin, PPF and coatings
Pros:
- Only pick here that is first choice on both lanes
- Residue-free rinse, which is the main thing black paint needs
- Restores coating hydrophobicity rather than depositing on top of it
Cons:
- Aggressive enough to strip a fresh carnauba wax if overdosed
- Premium price tier and a small bottle
Verdict: the safest single answer to the black car question, gloss or matte, coated or bare.
Perfect for: coated gloss black daily drivers, satin and matte wraps, and anyone who wants one bottle that works on both cars in the driveway.
Check the CarPro Reset on Amazon
#2 Chemical Guys Black Light: Best for Gloss Black Paint
This is the most on-keyword product in the category, and it is also the clearest example of the lane problem. Black Light is built specifically for black and dark paint with advanced synthetic lubricants and hyper-surfactants for a thick, slick foam, then adds dedicated gloss enhancers, optical brighteners and micro-refined oils that deepen a dark finish and help mask light swirl marks. It is pH-balanced and coating-safe, so it will not strip wax, sealant or ceramic. Black cherry scent, and it runs in a bucket, a foam gun or a foam cannon.
Those gloss enhancers are precisely why it is not matte-safe. Owners of black PPF and coated black cars report dirt floating off in a cannon and a noticeably deeper wet look, but forum purists argue the enhancers are a gimmick that a pure slick soap plus a dedicated glaze would beat. One naming trap: Chemical Guys also sells a Black Light glaze and sealant under the same name, which is a different product.
Specs:
- pH-balanced and coating-safe
- Synthetic lubricants and hyper-surfactants
- Gloss enhancers, optical brighteners and micro-refined oils
- Bucket, foam gun or foam cannon
Pros:
- Purpose-built for dark paint rather than adapted to it
- Thick foam with good cling on vertical panels
- Noticeable depth on single-stage and clear-coated black
Cons:
- Not matte-safe, and the label makes no claim that it is
- Gloss additives mean an extra rinse to avoid streaks if you over-apply
Verdict: the pick if you want the soap itself to do some of the visual work on gloss black.
Perfect for: gloss black and dark blue or dark grey paint, waxed, sealed or coated.
Check the Chemical Guys Black Light on Amazon
#3 Adam's Car Wash Shampoo: Best Value for Both Finishes
Adam's is the inexpensive crossover. It is pH-neutral with no wax or gloss additives, so it neither strips a coating nor deposits anything that would streak a black panel, and the manufacturer lists it as safe on all surfaces including glass, headlights, plastic, paint, raw aluminium and matte finishes. The SDS backs the neutral claim at pH 7.4, which is one of the few hard numbers available in this category.
Real-world behaviour matches the spec closely enough: thick slick suds, a clean spot-free rinse, and it is one of very few mass-market soaps you can use in direct sun without it flashing dry on a hot black hood. The wildberry scent and deep blue colour are cosmetic. Reports of minor batch-to-batch variation in foaming show up from time to time, and matte purists will still prefer a dedicated matte formula, but for a garage holding one gloss car and one matte car this is the cheapest genuinely correct answer.
Specs:
- pH 7.4 per SDS, no wax or gloss additives
- Listed safe on paint, glass, headlights, plastic, raw aluminium and matte finishes
- Usable in direct sunlight
- Bucket, foam gun or foam cannon
Pros:
- Matte-safe and gloss-friendly at a budget price
- Rinses spot-free, which black paint rewards
- Works in sun, useful on a hot dark hood
Cons:
- Occasionally inconsistent foam between batches
- Additive-free means no gloss enhancement on dark paint
Verdict: the one to buy if the same bottle has to serve a matte car and a gloss car.
Perfect for: two-car garages with mixed finishes and anyone who washes in the sun.
Check the Adam's Car Wash Shampoo on Amazon
#4 P&S Pearl Auto Shampoo: Slickest Feel
Pearl is the pro-shop favourite, part of the Renny Doyle Double Black Collection, and the reason people name it is one word: slickness. It is pH-balanced, 100% biodegradable and phosphate-free, with excellent foam stability and enough lubricity that the mitt glides in a way mass-market budget soaps simply do not. It encapsulates grime, leaves existing protection intact, and carries no gloss enhancer or wax additives.
Dilution is generous. The bucket ratio runs 80:1 to 128:1, roughly an ounce per gallon, and a foam cannon takes it around 5:1, so a gallon covers a lot of washes. The lemon scent is light. It is a cleaning shampoo rather than a maintenance-only shampoo, so dirty cars can be handled with a slightly richer mix. Residue-free rinsing matters more on black than anywhere else, and this is where Pearl consistently gets praised.
Specs:
- pH-balanced, biodegradable, phosphate-free
- No gloss enhancer or wax additives
- Bucket dilution 80:1 to 128:1 (about 1 oz per gallon)
- Foam cannon around 5:1
Pros:
- Outstanding lubricity for the price per wash
- Rinses completely clean, the key trait for black
- Works on matte and gloss, no depositing additives
Cons:
- Richer mixing is sometimes needed on heavily soiled paint
- Less widely stocked than the big-box brands
Verdict: the pick when swirl protection is the priority and you want maximum glide.
Perfect for: gloss black paint under high scrutiny, and detailers who value feel over foam volume.
Check the P&S Pearl Auto Shampoo on Amazon
#5 Gyeon Q²M Bathe: Best Premium Maintenance Soap
Bathe is a pure maintenance shampoo built to work with sealants and coatings rather than on top of them. The manufacturer lists pH 6, no oils, no polymers, no waxes and no gloss enhancers, which makes it safe on a matte finish and correct on a coated gloss black car for the same reason. It is heavily concentrated, dilutable up to 1:500 with 20 to 30 ml covering a 10 to 15 litre bucket, with strong glide and good foam stability and a clean rinse.
Because it deposits nothing, it does not clog coating pores or build a film on a dark panel over time. One naming trap worth knowing: Bathe+ is a different product, pH-neutral but infused with SiO2, and the SiO2 collapses foam within seconds and can leave high spots if it dries on the panel. If the label has a plus, it is not the soap described here.
Specs:
- pH 6, no oils, polymers, waxes or gloss enhancers
- Dilution up to 1:500 (20 to 30 ml per 10 to 15 L)
- Designed for ceramic coatings, sealants and waxes
- Safe on gloss and matte
Pros:
- Deposits nothing, so no film builds on dark paint
- Very economical at 1:500
- Correct for both lanes
Cons:
- Premium tier pricing per bottle
- No SiO2 top-up, which some coated-car owners want from a wash
Verdict: the maintenance soap to keep on the shelf alongside a coating.
Perfect for: ceramic-coated gloss black cars and matte finishes that need a pure, unfussy wash.
Check the Gyeon Q²M Bathe on Amazon
#6 Griot's Garage Super-Concentrated Car Wash: Best Budget Crossover
Griot's Super-Concentrated is pH-neutral and officially rated safe for all finishes including matte paint and vinyl wraps, which puts it in the same lane as the expensive crossovers at the lowest entry price here. The concentration is the headline figure: one ounce makes two gallons of wash solution. It is high-lubricity and will not disturb wax or ceramic coatings, so it is a sensible default for a coated black car that gets washed often.
Watch the name at the shelf. Griot's also sells Brilliant Finish Car Wash, a different product that contains gloss-enhancing brighteners at a 128:1 dilution and is not flagged matte-safe. If the label says Brilliant Finish, it is the gloss lane. A separate reviewer found Brilliant Finish needed about 1.25 oz per gallon to feel properly slick, so the label dose on that one is worth exceeding slightly.
Specs:
- pH-neutral
- 1 oz concentrates to 2 gallons of wash solution
- Safe for all finishes including matte paint and vinyl wraps
- Will not disturb wax or ceramic coatings
Pros:
- Lowest-cost route into a genuinely matte-safe soap
- Extremely economical per wash
- No depositing additives to streak a black panel
Cons:
- Not a gloss-enhancing soap, so no darkening effect
- The Brilliant Finish sibling is easy to confuse it with
Verdict: the value pick when you need one matte-safe soap for everything.
Perfect for: high-frequency washers and mixed gloss and matte garages on a budget.
Check the Griot's Garage Super-Concentrated Car Wash on Amazon
#7 Chemical Guys Meticulous Matte: Best Matte Specialist
Meticulous Matte is marketed by Chemical Guys as the first matte-safe car wash soap that will not add unwanted gloss or shine, and the formula claim is specific: no gloss enhancers and no wax. It is pH-balanced, high-lubricity and designed to foam in a way that reduces scratching on sensitive matte and satin surfaces, and it will not stain or discolour a vinyl wrap.
Dilution is roughly 1 oz per 5-gallon bucket, going up to 5 oz if you are using it to strip old wax or sealant, and a foam cannon takes 1 to 3 oz per 32 oz of water. The fruity bubble gum scent is the one part matte purists complain about. It can be used on gloss paint too, it simply adds no shine. The practical warning that comes up repeatedly from matte owners applies to every soap in this lane: any residue shows on matte, so rinse until the water runs clear and never let the foam dry on the panel. Keep a mitt dedicated to matte, separate from the one used on gloss.
Specs:
- pH-balanced, no gloss enhancers and no wax
- High-lubricity, high-foam formula for matte and satin
- Bucket about 1 oz per 5 gal (up to 5 oz to strip old protection)
- Foam cannon 1 to 3 oz per 32 oz
Pros:
- The default matte recommendation on owner forums
- Will not discolour or stain wraps
- Available in a small size to try before committing
Cons:
- Heavy foam and a strong scent are not to everyone's taste
- Gloss cars get no benefit over a cheaper pure soap
Verdict: the safest first stop for factory matte, satin paint and matte wrap.
Perfect for: matte and satin wrapped cars, factory flat finishes, and Cybertruck stainless.
Check the Chemical Guys Meticulous Matte on Amazon
#8 Dr. Beasley's Matte Body Wash: Best Purist Matte Soap
Dr. Beasley's removes the entire additive category rather than reducing it: no wax, no paraffin, no silicones, no oils and no fillers. It is pH-balanced and readily biodegradable, high-foaming and high-lubricity for a formula that has nothing left in it to prevent scratching. The manufacturer is explicit that it will not turn a gloss finish matte, so it is safe on satin and gloss paint as well.
It exists for the owner who finds Meticulous Matte's foam and scent too much and wants the thinnest possible film left behind on a flat panel. The trade-offs are real: it sits in the premium tier, owner feedback is scarcer than for the mass-market picks, and availability is often through third-party sellers. If your matte car is the garage queen, this is the bottle that leaves the least on the paint.
Specs:
- pH-balanced, readily biodegradable
- No wax, paraffin, silicones, oils or fillers
- High-foam, high-lubricity
- Will not turn a gloss finish matte
Pros:
- Cleanest possible residue profile for matte
- Usable on satin and gloss without adding shine
- Low-suds alternative to foam-heavy matte soaps
Cons:
- Premium price, less owner feedback than mass-market soaps
- Frequently sold through third parties rather than direct
Verdict: the choice when a matte finish matters more than cost or convenience.
Perfect for: owner-maintained matte and satin cars where the flat look is the whole point.
Check the Dr. Beasley's Matte Body Wash on Amazon
#9 Meguiar's Gold Class: Best Budget Gloss Soap
Gold Class is the long-standing enthusiast gateway soap, and the chemistry is unusually well documented for the price. A third-party SDS analysis puts it at pH 7.5 with a multi-surfactant system of 14 disclosed components, alcohol ethoxysulfate as the primary cleaning agent alongside amphoteric and nonionic surfactants, plus integrated paint conditioners that reveal colour and clarity and enhance gloss. It is biodegradable and safe on clear coats, and it preserves wax, sealant and coating.
Dilution is about 1 oz per gallon in a bucket and 5:1 in a foam cannon. Two things to know before buying it for black paint. First, it is not matte-safe, because those conditioners are the point of the product. Second, it is not the slickest premium option, and over-concentrating or under-rinsing can leave a faint film, which a black panel will show under direct light before any lighter colour does.
Specs:
- pH 7.5 per third-party SDS analysis
- 14 disclosed components, alcohol ethoxysulfate primary surfactant
- Integrated paint conditioners for gloss
- Bucket about 1 oz per gallon, foam cannon 5:1
Pros:
- Genuinely affordable for a gloss-enhancing wash
- Long track record on waxed and sealed dark paint
- Biodegradable and clear-coat safe
Cons:
- Not matte-safe
- Can leave a faint film if overdosed or under-rinsed
Verdict: the budget gloss soap for a waxed black car, provided you measure rather than pour.
Perfect for: waxed or sealed gloss black cars on a tight budget.
Check the Meguiar's Gold Class on Amazon
#10 Chemical Guys Mr. Pink: Best for Foam Volume
Mr. Pink is a super-concentrated maintenance shampoo rated for up to 1:4000 dilution, with 1 to 2 oz handling a 5-gallon bucket. It uses what Chemical Guys calls premium super polymers to encapsulate road grime plus hyper-surfactants for lubrication, is safe on wax and sealant, and rinses clean. Foam production is its strength, in a bucket, a foam gun or a cannon.
Two caveats. The polymer content is exactly why matte owners are told to avoid it, so it belongs in the gloss lane. And the most repeated critique of it is that it favours suds over cleaning power, which is a fair description of a soap whose selling point is the show it puts on. On a lightly soiled black daily that trade is fine. On a winter-filthy car, step up to something with more bite.
Specs:
- pH-balanced maintenance shampoo
- Up to 1:4000 dilution, 1 to 2 oz per 5-gallon bucket
- Polymer and hyper-surfactant formula, high foaming
- Safe on wax and sealant, not matte-safe
Pros:
- Very high foam volume for the price
- Extremely economical dilution
- Rinses clean when dosed correctly
Cons:
- Not matte-safe due to polymer content
- Foam-forward rather than cleaning-forward
Verdict: a good gloss-lane budget soap if dramatic foam is part of why you enjoy washing.
Perfect for: lightly soiled gloss black cars and foam cannon users who want visible foam.
Check the Chemical Guys Mr. Pink on Amazon
Comparison Table
| Product | Lane | pH | Bucket dilution | Foam cannon | Tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CarPro Reset | Both | 7 | 1:400 to 1:500 | About 1:9 | $$$ |
| Chemical Guys Black Light | Gloss | Neutral (not listed) | Not stated | Not stated | $$ |
| Adam's Car Wash Shampoo | Both | 7.4 (SDS) | Not stated | Not stated | $$ |
| P&S Pearl Auto Shampoo | Both | Neutral (not listed) | 80:1 to 128:1 | About 5:1 | $$$ |
| Gyeon Q²M Bathe | Both | 6 | Up to 1:500 | Not stated | $$$ |
| Griot's Super-Concentrated | Both | Neutral (not listed) | 1 oz per 2 gal | Not stated | $ |
| Chemical Guys Meticulous Matte | Matte | Neutral (not listed) | About 1 oz per 5 gal | 1 to 3 oz per 32 oz | $$ |
| Dr. Beasley's Matte Body Wash | Matte | Neutral (not listed) | Not stated | Not stated | $$$ |
| Meguiar's Gold Class | Gloss | 7.5 (third-party SDS) | About 1 oz per gal | 5:1 | $ |
| Chemical Guys Mr. Pink | Gloss | Neutral (not listed) | Up to 1:4000 | Not stated | $ |
Which Car Wash Soap Should You Buy?
Match the bottle to the paint, then to the budget.
Gloss black, ceramic coated. CarPro Reset first, Gyeon Q²M Bathe second. Both are pure, both rinse clean, and Reset restores beading on the coating rather than sitting on top of it. If adding protection after the wash is part of the routine, the ceramic coating boosters and spray sealants guide covers what to top it with.
Gloss black, waxed or sealed, and you want the wet look. Chemical Guys Black Light is the most purpose-built option, with Meguiar's Gold Class as the budget version. Both leave something behind by design, which is the point and also the reason to rinse thoroughly.
Gloss black on the tightest budget. Mr. Pink for foam, Gold Class for gloss and a longer track record. Neither is the slickest thing in this roundup, but both are correct on waxed paint when dosed properly. The wider budget roundup by price tier covers the rest of the field.
Matte black, satin wrap or factory flat finish. Chemical Guys Meticulous Matte for the mainstream option, Dr. Beasley's Matte Body Wash if you want the smallest possible residue profile. Do not reach for a black-paint soap here; Black Light and Mr. Pink are both wrong for this lane.
One bottle for a matte car and a gloss car. Adam's is the cheapest, Griot's Super-Concentrated is even cheaper per wash, P&S Pearl is the slickest, and CarPro Reset or Gyeon Q²M Bathe are the premium answers. None of them add gloss, which is exactly what the matte car needs and no disadvantage for a coated gloss car.
Maximum slickness on black paint. P&S Pearl. The glide is the reason it has a following in professional shops.
Whichever you choose, the wash media matter as much as the soap. A dedicated wash mitt per lane and clean, correctly washed towels do more for swirl prevention than a step up in shampoo price, which is where the guides to wash mitts and brushes and to washing and caring for microfiber pick up.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Will a matte soap make my glossy black car look matte?
No. A matte-safe soap simply adds no gloss; it does not remove the shine that is already on the paint. Dr. Beasley's states directly that its Matte Body Wash will not turn a gloss finish matte, and it is safe to use on satin and gloss paint. The reverse is not true: a gloss soap with wax or gloss enhancers can leave a patchy sheen on a matte panel that cannot be polished out.
Q: Can I use one soap on both my matte car and my gloss car?
Yes, if the formula carries no wax, gloss enhancers, silicones, oils or fillers. That is the whole matte-safe criterion. Products like CarPro Reset, Gyeon Q²M Bathe, P&S Pearl, Adam's Car Wash Shampoo and Griot's Super-Concentrated meet it, and none of them disadvantages a gloss finish. What you cannot do is run a gloss soap on the matte car and hope the additives wash off.
Q: Will a black-car soap like Black Light work on a matte wrap?
No. Chemical Guys Black Light is built around gloss enhancers, optical brighteners and micro-refined oils that deepen dark paint, and those are precisely the ingredients that produce a semi-gloss haze on a matte or satin wrap. The word black in the product name describes the colour it flatters, not the finish it tolerates.
Q: Does more foam mean a better clean?
No. Foam volume is a poor quality signal. Foam's real job is to cling to vertical panels and soften the danger layer of dirt before your mitt makes contact, and a foam pre-soak does not remove bonded traffic film on its own. A low-foaming concentrate can out-clean a dramatic-looking one, and suds that actually carry dirt matter more than big bubbles.
Q: Why does my black paint still get swirl marks if I use a slick soap?
Because the soap is only the lubrication half of the equation. Swirls come from dragging grit across the panel, and the usual causes are circular wiping, a single-bucket wash, a mitt or towel that has picked up contamination, or drying with a dirty towel. Straight-line strokes, the two-bucket method with grit guards, a rinse until the water runs clear, and contact-free or plush-towel drying are what close the gap.
Conclusion
The black car question resolves into two answers, and most of the confusion in this category comes from treating them as one. Gloss black wants maximum lubrication and a residue-free rinse, with optional gloss enhancers if you want the soap to add depth. Matte black, satin and factory flat finishes want the opposite: nothing left on the surface at all. A shampoo built for black paint can be the right bottle for one and the wrong bottle for the other.
CarPro Reset is the single pick that serves both, at pH 7 with no gloss enhancers, polymers or wax, and a bucket dilution of 1:400 to 1:500. Below it, Adam's Car Wash Shampoo and Griot's Super-Concentrated Car Wash are the affordable crossovers, P&S Pearl is the slickest thing here for gloss black, and Chemical Guys Meticulous Matte or Dr. Beasley's Matte Body Wash are the dedicated matte answers. On the gloss side, Chemical Guys Black Light is the most purpose-built for dark paint, and Meguiar's Gold Class is the budget gloss pick, both with the caveat that they should never touch a matte panel.
Buy for the finish you actually have, dose the concentrate correctly rather than pouring generously, and spend the difference on a second wash mitt and a good drying towel. The technique is what protects black paint. The bottle only gives you the margin.
